The Icons That Made Us Famous
The Reuben
1/4 pound of thinly sliced Corned Beef Brisket, Hot Sauerkraut, Melted Swiss Cheese, and our Famous Russian Dressing; served on Grilled Rye Bread.
The Manhattan
Oven-Roasted Breast of Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Russian Dressing; served on a Grilled Onion Roll.
The Superior
One of our famous 1/2 lb Triple Deckers! New York Pastrami, Oven-Roasted Breast of Turkey, Melted Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Russian Dressing, and Tomato; on Grilled Rye Bread.
Roast Beef Sub
Oven-roasted rare roast beef served with sharp provolone, lettuce. tomato, black pepper, oregano, red onion, pepperoncinis, and mayonnaise served on a grilled French Roll
Pastrami Fries
A New York Deli original — Hand cut fries, piled high, and drizzled with our house-made dressing.
Pastrami Fries
Grilled onions, chopped pastrami, melted Sharp Cooper American cheese, drizzled with your choice of Original or Spicy Russian Dressing.
View Our MenuBagels Bagels Bagels
Authentic New York City Bagels
Plain, Everything,
and Beyond
From classic plain and sesame to everything and blueberry— Sold single or by the 1/2 dozen.
View Our MenuSignature Bottled Dressing
Take home the flavors you love. Our house-made dressings are bottled fresh and ready to bring the New York Deli experience to your table.
Original Russian Dressing
Our classic house-made Russian dressing — the secret behind every great Reuben. Creamy, tangy, and perfectly balanced.
Spicy Russian Dressing
All the bold flavor of our original with a kick of heat. Perfect for those who like a little fire.
Caesar Dressing
Rich, garlicky, and made fresh in-house. Our Caesar dressing is as good on a salad as it is straight off the spoon.
Available in-store
Ask for a bottle at the counter.
Take the taste of New York Deli home with you. Our house-made dressings are up for grabs!
Find UsOur Desserts
No meal at New York Deli is complete without something sweet. Save room — you'll want it.
Cheesecake
with Toppings
Rich, creamy New York-style cheesecake topped with banana slices, whipped cream, and banana caramel drizzle.
View Our MenuThe Perfect Companion
A true New York Deli staple — Dr. Brown's sodas have been the perfect sandwich companion for generations.
Dr. Brown's Sodas
No deli sandwich is complete without one. We carry the full lineup of Dr. Brown's classics — grab one cold and enjoy it the New York Deli way.
Rated #1 Deli in the Rio Grande Valley
For over two decades, New York Deli has been McAllen's most beloved deli — earning five-star praise from generations of loyal guests across the Rio Grande Valley.